top of page

When do your rights have to be read to you

  • Writer: Ed Shaw Law
    Ed Shaw Law
  • May 27
  • 1 min read

I have written on this topic before, but, because it is a source of alot of misunderstanding among the general public, it needs more attention.  


Police shows for decades have shown people being arrested and read the Miranda warning, 'their rights', you have the right to remain silent, etc.  Many people assume, understandably, that the police have to read those rights when they arrest you, and, if they do not, you may be able to get the case thrown out. 


That is not true, the rights are only required if the police want to use a statement that you make when they question you while you are in custody, i.e. arrested, in the control of the police, or, at a jail.  There is no law that the rights have to be read when the police arrest you, it is only if they want to question you after the arrest.  The rights also do not cover voluntary statements, meaning if the police do not ask you questions, but, you blurt out on your own statements that hurt your case, they can be used even with no rights reading.


Bottom line, when you are arrested, you are wise to use your right to remain silent, except for stating your name, and, a list of any medications that you will need with you at the jail.  TV and the internet can be fun and interesting, but, as sources of information about how the real world legal system works they are not a good bet.  


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
The logo of Ed Shaw Law, P.A., a general practice law firm serving Greater Minnesota

Small Town Care. Statewide Strength.

Ed Shaw Law

Brainerd Lakes Area

722 South 6th Street

Brainerd, Minnesota 56401

St. Cloud Area

14 Seventh Street

St. Cloud, Minnesota 56303

Meetings By Appointment Only

Office Hours: M-F, 8am -5pm

To book a consultation, please:

Call us at (218) 825-7030

Email us at receptionist@edshawlaw.com 

OR Click the link below to find a time that works for us both.

© 2026 By Ed Shaw Law, P.A.

Brainerd and St. Cloud General Practice Attorneys

Serving Central and Northern Minnesota for Family Law Matters, Harassment Restraining Orders and Orders for Protection, Child Protection (CHIPS) Cases, Criminal Defense, Probate, Wills and Estate Planning, Property Disputes, Mediation, Negotiation, Business Formation, Contract Drafting, Elder Law Matters, Construction Law Disputes, Civil Litigation, and More!

bottom of page